Does this still fall under the noise blanket

[MountKuma]

https://mountkuma.bandcamp.com/album/ta ... rable-heat


The newest release from late last year. Picked up some new toys traveling Japan and Taiwan and put this out when I arrived home in Australia afterward.

Strays away from Harsher Noise toward ambient but wanted to know if it still falls under the noise blanket in the eyes of Noiseguide

https://mountkuma.bandcamp.com/album/ta ... rable-heat

[s.p.i.n.]

no, that's definitely music

[xdugef]

no, that's definitely music

Sure if the only noise that is "real noise" is HNW

[s.p.i.n.]

no, that's definitely music

Sure if the only noise that is "real noise" is HNW

or done without guitars

[s.p.i.n.]

I think field recordings are noise.. what I heard in the link was beautiful music.

[xdugef]

I think field recordings are noise..

What if it's a field recording of music?

[xdugef]

no, that's definitely music

Sure if the only noise that is "real noise" is HNW

or done without guitars

I just don't like guitars at noise shows.. doesn't really have anything to do with is it noise or not

[s.p.i.n.]

I think field recordings are noise..

What if it's a field recording of music?

Like a live album?

[s.p.i.n.]

I just don't like guitars at noise shows.. doesn't really have anything to do with is it noise or not

Aww..but they like you

[xdugef]

I think field recordings are noise..

What if it's a field recording of music?

Like a live album?

not exactly.. more like you encounter music being played in some form while walking around recording

[xdugef]

I just don't like guitars at noise shows.. doesn't really have anything to do with is it noise or not

Aww..but they like you

It's nothing personal

[Fletcher]

Did you set out to create noise? I guess you can call it noise if thats what you want it to be.
Might be better marketing it as something else though, depending on your intended audience.

[fire]

its melodic noisescape, the edge of music, it evokes an emotional response similar to music

noise as a genre is pretty tough to nail down, but consider this:

music stimulates certain emotions and thoughts

noise is often crafted to avoid evoking these

nobody mistakes a violin for a jackhammer

[guill pizarro]

Not sure, but I dig it!

[jliat]

The classic...

"4′33″ (pronounced "Four minutes, thirty-three seconds" or just "Four thirty-three"[1]) is a three-movement composition[2][3] by American experimental composer John Cage (1912–1992). It was composed in 1952, for any instrument or combination of instruments, and the score instructs the performer(s) not to play their instrument(s) during the entire duration of the piece throughout the three movements. The piece consists of the sounds of the environment that the listeners hear while it is performed,[4] although it is commonly perceived as "four minutes thirty-three seconds of silence".[5][6] The title of the piece refers to the total length in minutes and seconds of a given performance, 4′33″ being the total length of the first public performance.[7]"

Noise - yes - but not made by the composer or performer - music - well yes its considered so...